One in five construction sites fail safety inspections
One in five construction sites failed safety checks during the first
five days of an intensive inspection initiative in Merseyside and
Cheshire.
Inspectors from the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) visited a total
167 sites in the two counties between 20 and 24 February, but 32 were
found to have working practices that could put workers at risk.
The inspections were carried out as part of a month-long drive across
Great Britain to improve health and safety in one of the country's most
dangerous industries. Inspectors are targeting sites where
refurbishment or repair work in being carried out, with the aim of
reducing the risk of death, injury and ill health.
The primary focus is on high-risk activity including working at
height and 'good order', such as ensuring sites are clean and tidy with
clear access routes. Attention is also being paid to structural
stability, public protection, fire safety issues and asbestos.
During the visits in Merseyside and Cheshire, HSE inspectors issued
29 Prohibition Notices stopping work activities immediately and 15
Improvement Notices requiring changes to be made to working practices.
Half of the notices related to unsafe work being carried out at height.
Falls from height remain one of the most common causes of deaths and
major injuries in the construction sector in Great Britain, with more
than five incidents recorded every day.
The purpose of the initiative is to remind those working in
construction that poor standards are unacceptable, and could result in
enforcement action.
Neil Jamieson, HSE Principal Inspector for Construction, said:
"The majority of the sites we visited were meeting acceptable
standards but sadly one in five weren't, putting the lives and health of
workers at risk.
"The fact that half of the enforcement notices we issued related to
work at height shows that companies still aren't doing enough to tackle
one of the biggest causes of death and major injury in the sector.
"Implementing simple, inexpensive changes, or just a moment of extra
thought, could prevent someone being killed or seriously injured.
Employers should create an atmosphere where workers can raise concerns
without fearing for their jobs."
HSE and smoke free legislation
HSE is not responsible for enforcing the legislation but
will fully support Local Authority officers both in raising employers’
awareness of their responsibilities and in encouraging employers and
employees to comply with the new legislation above. HSE inspectors will
bring matters of concern to the attention of the employer, particularly
if it involves a number of smokers or if there is a failure to display
warning notices. Should the employer resist acting on this advice, the
inspector will then bring the matter to the attention of the appropriate
local authority. Any complaints received by HSE about the smoking ban
will be referred to the appropriate local authority.
HSE will also support the new legislation by sending out
flyers, and work in partnership with local authorities on health
promotional matters as appropriate.
Premises exempt from smoke free legislation
Health and Safety legislation will continue to require
employers, in premises permitted exemptions under the smoke-free law, to
reduce the risk to the health and safety of their employees from second
hand smoking to as low a level as is reasonably practicable.
In exempted premises, HSE will continue to promote a
sensible, proportionate management of second hand smoking to as low a
level as is reasonably practicable and to encourage employers to adopt
smoking policies in the workplace which give precedence to the wishes of
non-smokers not to be exposed to second hand smoking.
Even with new smoke-free legislation, HSE’s advice on
protecting employees from the effects of second hand smoke remains
unchanged in that:
- Employers should have a specific policy on smoking in the workplace.
- Employers should take action to reduce the risk to the
health and safety of their employees from second hand smoke to as low a
level as is reasonably practicable.
- Smoking policy should give priority to the needs of non-smokers who do not wish to breathe tobacco smoke.
- Employers should consult their employees and their
representatives on the appropriate smoking policy to suit their
particular workplace.
Failure to identify asbestos put workers at risk
A Cardiff company has been fined for putting the health of demolition
workers at risk after a building survey failed to identify the presence
of asbestos.
Between 15 and 25 January 2010 PHH Environmental (UK) Ltd was
commissioned to produce an asbestos survey on the soon to be demolished
Old Castle Cinema in Merthyr Tydfil.
Merthyr Tydfil Magistrates' Court heard that PHH's client relied on
this survey to help its demolition company plan the work. But once
demolition was underway, workers discovered asbestos and found they had
disturbed it.
PHH Environmental (UK) Limited, of Titan House, Cardiff Bay Business
Centre, Lewis Road, Cardiff, pleaded guilty to breaching Section 3 (1)
of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974. The company was today
fined £5,000 and ordered to pay costs of £3,000.
HSE inspector Steve Richardson investigated the case. He said:
"Anyone carrying out refurbishment or demolition work relies upon
accurate asbestos surveys to reduce the risk of them being exposed to
deadly asbestos fibres. It is essential that those surveys are
comprehensive, intrusive and undertaken by competent persons - if not
lives are needlessly put at risk."
Unsafe asbestos removal put people at risk
A building company in Bradford-on-Avon has been fined after it
removed an asbestos insulation board (AIB) ceiling in an unsafe manner,
leaving workers and residents at risk of exposure to asbestos fibres.
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) told Chippenham Magistrates'
Court that D B Construction (West Wilts) Ltd carried out unsafe work
while refurbishing a house in Bradford-on-Avon between 29 November and
10 December 2010.
An AIB ceiling was removed in an uncontrolled manner, which put
employees, subcontractors and the homeowners and their young children at
risk of asbestos exposure.
The court heard an electrician on site raised concerns the ceiling
boards being removed from could contain asbestos and he arranged for the
material to be analysed before beginning work.
An analyst visited the site and advised work should cease until the
contaminated area had been cleaned of asbestos debris. HSE later
confirmed the ceiling boards contained both white and the more hazardous
brown asbestos.
HSE found that DB Construction had failed to investigate whether
asbestos was present in the building before work started and when
removing the ceiling boards its employees and sub contractors failed to
identify the material and broke up the boards releasing airborne
asbestos fibres. The boards and debris were then removed in open bags
and left in the garden in a breach of safety rules.
HSE inspector, Helena Tinton said after the prosecution:
"Asbestos widely known to be a hazardous material and asbestos fibre
exposure is linked to a number of serious diseases, including cancer and
scarring of the lungs. As such, work with materials containing higher
risk asbestos, including asbestos insulation board, is a licensed
activity with work only carried out by trained people under tightly
controlled conditions.
"As a building contractor engaged in refurbishment work, D B
Construction should have been aware of this and yet these ceiling boards
were removed in an uncontrolled manner over a period of several hours,
which resulted in the spread of airborne asbestos fibres inside and
outside the property, leaving workers and the family at risk of
exposure."
Film company fined after cameraman hurt on set
A production company has been fined after a cameraman fell more than three metres from the set of a forthcoming major film.
The 62-year-old was working on the set of 47 Ronin at Shepperton
Studios, Middlesex, when he fell through an opening in the floor. The
opening was for access to a raised area via stairs, but had not been
guarded to prevent people falling through it.
The cameraman, who suffered bruising and suspected broken ribs, was
employed by Warrior Productions Limited, which was responsible for the
production of the film in the United Kingdom and was in control of the
set.
A Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigation into the incident
on 10 May 2010 found that because the film is set in 18th Century Japan
the set had been built without edge protection to make it look
authentic. Temporary protection had been added in some areas but not
where the cameraman fell. Guardrails were added immediately after the
incident.
Warrior Productions Limited, of Prospect House, New Oxford Street,
London, was fined £300, ordered to pay costs of £10,500 and ordered to
pay the injured person £300 compensation for breaching Regulation 6(3)
of the Work at Height Regulations 2005.
After the hearing HSE inspector Stephen Green said:
"At the time of the incident it was dark and there was no lighting on
the platform. Numerous people had been or were still on the platform,
and therefore were all exposed to the risk. The cameraman was lucky to
escape with bruising and suspected cracked ribs as falls from a similar
height can cause serious or even fatal injuries.
"The company was aware there were unguarded edges on the set. Some
areas had temporary protection added, but there was no full assessment
of the whole set. The guardrails fitted after the incident would have
prevented the fall and were quick and easy to install.
"Alternatively other measures could have been put in place if the guardrails were visible on camera during filming."
Worker seriously burned after cutting through 11,000 volt cable in Worcester
Two companies have been fined after a demolition worker was engulfed
in flames when he cut through a live 11,000 volt cable at an electricity
substation in Worcester.
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) prosecuted Birmingham firm DSM
Demolition Ltd and Halesowen-based Gould Singleton Architects Ltd (GSA)
following the incident on 14 July 2006.
Worcester Crown Court heard today that DSM was demolishing a metal
casting foundry in Wainwright Road, Worcester, when employee Lee Harris,
35, was told to cut through a cable, which was connected to a switching
unit on a substation on the site, which was still live.
As the machine he was using to cut through the cable came into
contact with the live conductors, he was engulfed by flames, suffering
20 per cent burns, which have left him with permanent disabilities and
requiring skin grafts.
HSE's investigation into the incident found that neither planning
supervisor GSA nor demolition contractor DSM had made adequate checks to
ensure that the electricity on the site had been disconnected.
GSA had told DSM that all services to the site had been terminated
when actually the power supply remained live. DSM should have ensured
that the electrical services had been disconnected before starting
demolition, but failed to do so.
DSM Demolition Ltd, of Arden Road, Birmingham, was found guilty on 26
September 2011 of breaching Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at
Work etc Act. The company was today fined £40,000 and ordered to pay
£100,000 costs.
Gould Singleton Architects Ltd, of Whitehall Road, Halesowen, pleaded
guilty to breaching Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc
Act 1974 and Regulation 15(3)(e) of the Construction (Design and
Management) Regulations 1994. The company was fined £20,000 and ordered
to pay £20,872 costs.
Speaking after the hearing, HSE inspector Tariq Khan said:
"Live electricity and gas services pose a serious risk of death or
serious injury to demolition workers. It is essential that companies
working in this sector take proper precautions to protect their workers.
"Neither of the two companies prosecuted today had made adequate
checks to ensure that the power supply to the cable required to be cut
by Mr Harris had been terminated. Had they done so then this incident
would never have happened and Mr Harris would not have suffered such
serious injuries.
"Construction, design and management co-ordinators must ensure that
the information they pass on to contractors which could affect the
safety of their workers is correct. Likewise, demolition contractors
must follow safe systems of work at all times and ensure they check
information provided to them about services on site with independent,
competent sources."
Low take-up of Fit for Work services revealed
Both
the volume and profile of individuals who engaged with a trial of
services aimed at helping workers return to, or stay in, work, were not
in line with expectations, according to an evaluation of the pilots'
first year in operation.
Conceived on the back of Dame Carol
Black's review of the health of the working-age population, the previous
Government launched a trial of Fit for Work Services (FFWS) in March
2010. The services, which cover 11 diverse areas of Britain, provide
personalised, case-managed support for workers in the early stages of
sickness absence, or ill health in order to expedite a return to work
and support job retention. All services provided clinical and
non-clinical support.
Presenting its findings from the first year
of the evaluation, a Government-commissioned consortium - including the
likes of the Institute for Employment Studies (IES) and the National
Institute of Economic and Social Research - said it is still unclear
whether the pilots have been helping individuals get back to work
quicker than they otherwise would have done, although qualitative
evidence from interviews indicated that they had.
The report's
authors note that by providing a range of services to support employees,
there is a danger that “they will wait until they have had their
'treatment' before returning to the workplace”. Conversely, they point
out that when they do return to work, this may be “more sustained, if
the issues causing or exacerbating the absence have been resolved”.
By
the end of March 2011, 6726 people had taken up the services - about 40
per cent of the expected total. Nearly all clients were employed and
two-thirds were workplace 'presentees' (still in work) rather than
absentees, who were the original target group. One of the main reasons
for the lower-than-expected take-up was the difficulties encountered in
generating referrals from GPs and employers.
Most clients had
either a mental-health condition, or a musculoskeletal disorder, with
the majority suffering from more than one health condition. More than
half of the clients had work-related concerns, such as lack of support
at work, harassment and bullying, and a fear that they could not cope
with work demands. Most thought their health condition had been made
worse by work.
Some 62 per cent of clients who were supported in
the first year had been discharged by the end of March 2011, and 74 per
cent of these individuals were back at work by the time they left the
service.
Commenting on the findings, Jim Hillage, director of
research at the IES, said: “This kind of support is particularly useful
for smaller businesses without the access to occupational health (OH)
that larger organisations have. The interim evaluation shows that this
kind of intervention has the potential to fill the gap between OH and
the health service. The final evaluation report will assess the impact
of the service on overall sickness absence and whether the benefits
outweigh the cost.”
Seven pilots have received funding to
continue to run for at least a second year. The final evaluation report
will also examine the role of employers in assisting return to work and
the issues the services face in helping employees negotiate their
return.
The full report can be accessed at: http://research.dwp.gov.uk/asd/asd5/report_abstracts/rr_abstracts/rra_792.asp